Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
SPECIAL GUEST STAR (against his knowledge) IS :iconandrew-ross-maclean:

You guys know when I get really excited about art geekery, I JUST CAN'T KEEP IT IN.  I also feel like composition is a really hard thing to learn, and all you can really do is try to learn "what is good" in composition, and then try to find examples until you can recognize it.  In addition, composition for comics is extra hard because you have to worry about the overall flow of the page as well as the composition of each individual panel.

So I was doing my spring cleaning of my message center and came on some new comic pages he uploaded, all of which are awesome, but take a particular look at this one: Head Lopper page 3 by Andrew-Ross-MacLean

This page is AMAZING.  I started watching this guy for his slick style and stayed for his crazy composition skills, and this page makes a particularly good example because his work is so clean and straight-forward, there's not a lot of noodling to distract from the motion lines.

1- We read left to right (thanks to MikeMoroney for pointing out my idiot type-o there,) and then up to down, so we start in the upper righthand corner here.  The hills shoot us right into that ship, tallest thing on the horizon, first focal point.

2- Little rock trail creates a path for us to go between the sea (extreme background) to the castle, (middle ground), and then the line of the bird picks it right up.

3- Line of the beak and back of the bird, up and around that wing with the considerate curved negative space behind the back wing.  Also, the bird is flying right>left, if it were the other way around, our natural inclination would be to follow it right off the page.

4- Strong diagonal is the main shape of the bird.  Shoots your eye right down to the second row.

5- Here's where it gets sexy.  Little moments of low-contrast details keep your eye interested and get you right into that upper left-hand corner again, where

6- Sharp diagonal line directs you into the next panel.  Shadow lying scientifically impossibly on the two walls that make a corner?  Doesn't matter if no-one questions it because it looks so right.  Also worth mentioning that ll the lines of the walls and windows in panel 2 are slightly warped to the right to help keep us going forward.  

7- Line is continued in the netting, again, low contrast and interesting detail as opposed to strong contrast which would indicate important content like in

8- Back with the bird, amazing action line up and over.

9- Line of wall and line of shadow funnel energy into that sword grip.  THAT'S A GRIP.  

10- Contrast of the light arm provides the direction.  Once again, down and over.  Panels at the end of a line can't keep going off to the right- that just falls off the page and takes you out of the flow.

11- All the rope lines continue that trajectory.  They're only unparallel for the sake of interest.  As with the cobwebs in 5, and the netting in 6, he's using repetitive objects to guide your eye and provide interest but at the same time demonstrating it's not something you really need to spend a lot of time with.

12- BIRD.  It's literally an arrow in the direction your eye is moving.

13- Prow (or whatever) hijacks the flow, reinforced by the hills and the negative shape of sky.

14- Simple diagonal shadow line like in panels 2&4 showing you where to go.  That finger has just come DOWN on that wick.

That's just the first pass look.  Obviously, you have to stray from this path to see a lot of what's going on, but if you feel like taking the time and looking at all the details, you'll find his page still works on every level.  For instance, on panel two, you need to get down to that sword and candle.  If you do so, you'll follow those warped window and wall lines down, where the sword stops you, and redirects you to the candle on the table.  Then that horizontal patch of light that it's in, and the up-and-to-the-right markings on the table guide you right into that netting on panel 3.  So hot.
Add a Comment:
Neil113 Featured By Owner Sep 10, 2013
toerning Featured By Owner Sep 13, 2013
hahaha Hey man!  Yeah as you can tell, THIS guy was already on my list!!!
klampdesign Featured By Owner Apr 14, 2013  Professional Digital Artist
Awesome! I love finding things like this.

This kinda stuff is the reason why The Incredibles is my favorite Pixar film - it's jam packed with amazing editing, framing, and motivated eye movements. Ugh, so good!
toerning Featured By Owner Apr 14, 2013
Hahaha it's so funny, because I keep hearing that kind of thing about the Incredibles and, like, intellectually I know that it's amazingly conceived and composed and every other thing, but whenever I go to watch it with this mission of "I'm going to see all the awesome things," I just get sucked right into the plot like I do every other time. Which, if we're being honest, is an even bigger success than all the dorky technical stuff combined.

Thanks! :heart:
klampdesign Featured By Owner Apr 15, 2013  Professional Digital Artist
Haha for sure. I think that's kinda the coolest thing about stuff like this: if you really succeed at it, people won't even know you've done it. I work at a game company and I've been doing UI recently and it's the same way. The best UI is the one the player doesn't even think about. It should just feel like an extension of the viewer's perceptions and bring them closer to the game experience.

Anyway, long story short, I like to nerd out on this kinda stuff, too. :)
jannin Featured By Owner Apr 12, 2013  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Mind = blown.
TuesdayNightCompany Featured By Owner Apr 12, 2013
I suck suck suck at composition, but I love it so. It's an abusive relationship.
I am geeking out with you on this one.
acesquad Featured By Owner Apr 10, 2013  Hobbyist Artist
Amazing work. Composition is something I struggle with and it really helps to see detailed analysis like this to figure out what really make a page sing. Thanks for this!
Andrew-Ross-MacLean Featured By Owner Apr 10, 2013
Many thanks, very flattered!
wisp Featured By Owner Apr 9, 2013  Professional General Artist
<3 This is fantastic! And now I have someone new to add to my watchlist! Informative and fun! And other catchy soundbites!
Spikie Featured By Owner Apr 9, 2013  Student General Artist
oooh wow, thanks for talking about this! I love comics and composition, and it's always very interesting to read about please do more
MikeMoroney Featured By Owner Apr 9, 2013  Student General Artist
not to be that guy but dont you mean we read left-to-right? not right-to-left?

that's my only thing with this post. beyond that its well written and super helpful! :D
toerning Featured By Owner Apr 9, 2013
Oh god. hahahahaha YOU ARE SO RIGHT I actually am severely directionally challenged haha

Thanks! :heart:
Add a Comment:

:icontoerning: More from toerning

Featured in Collections

Journals by mechacharibdys

More from DeviantArt


Submitted on
April 9, 2013


38,285 (3 today)
59 (who?)